Catholic theology is no basis for teaching Medicine

I just came across this smug and self-congratulatory article on the Sydney Archdiocese’s website:

When 106 students from the University of Notre Dame (UND) in Sydney are awarded their degree as Bachelors of Medicine and Surgery next month they will also make history as the first-ever graduates from Australia’s newest medical school.

For the Sydney campus of UND which was established just four years ago, the graduation of the young men and women as fully fledged doctors is an important milestone.

“Those graduating this year are fantastic people and are going to be wonderful doctors,” predicts the Dean of UND’s Sydney Medical School, Professor Christine Bennett. “They are involved and interested in global health and social justice issues and with their diligence and respect they have shown for the health services during their training, they are standouts both as medical professionals and as human beings.”

So what’s going on is that the Catholic Notre Dame University has, on its Sydney campus, introduced a Bachelor of Medicine/Surgery(MBBS) course, and the first lot of trainees are about to graduate.

Medicine, a Greek invention, usurped by the anti-science anti-human Catholic mob. Inquisition and burning at the stake as rewards for those daring to propose new knowledge and making scientific advancements. A fine academic tradition indeed.

So, what’s a MBBS course at a Catholic University like ? Well, first up, you have to realise that Catholic Universities operate within restrictions set by the Church, such as Pope JP II’s “APOSTOLIC CONSTITUTION OF THE SUPREME PONTIFF JOHN PAUL II ON CATHOLIC UNIVERSITIES”:

13. Since the objective of a Catholic University is to assure in an institutional manner a Christian presence in the university world confronting the great problems of society and culture(16), every Catholic University, as Catholic, must have the following essential characteristics:

“1. a Christian inspiration not only of individuals but of the university community as such;

2. a continuing reflection in the light of the Catholic faith upon the growing treasury of human knowledge, to which it seeks to contribute by its own research;

3. fidelity to the Christian message as it comes to us through the Church;

4. an institutional commitment to the service of the people of God and of the human family in their pilgrimage to the transcendent goal which gives meaning to life”(17).

Translation: Your ass is ours, and we will feed you our dogma and make sure you come out of our institution full of Catholic “inspiration”. I’d hate to think how those 106 godbots graduating from Notre Dame might have been “educated” in matters of female reproductive rights, contraception, abortion, IVF, or euthanasia/patient autonomy, to name a few. Because sure as hell, any of Notre Dame’s Uni courses consists of a “Core Curriculum“:

All undergraduate students at The University of Notre Dame Australia are required to complete three core units. These three units: Introduction to Philosophy, Ethics and Introduction to Theology constitute the Core Curriculum. These units combine together to provide students with basic skills in critical analysis, ethical thought and Catholic theologising in an academic context which brings the substance and values of the Catholic faith to the fore and into open and creative engagement with the deeper questions of individual and social life.

Oh, those famous Catholic Ethics. What’s included in the curriculum I wonder, a field trip to a Spanish orphanage to meet some stolen children? A child fucking workshop in Ireland? Visiting an AIDS clinic in Africa? Watching a season of “16 and pregnant” on MTV?

I pity those students. What a gargantuan waste of money, to be studying what should and could be a profession where true human ethics, true compassion and true scientific skills can go so far in making a difference for our patients, in such a sad excuse for an academic institution, that is based on the non-values and non-ethics of a mob of superstitious geronts in robes, who have done their utmost for centuries to stifle scientific progress, and to replace real humanist ethics with their dogma of original sin and human suffering in the name of their non-existent celestial dictator.
Catholic dogma is not going to produce competent doctors. Procedurally and theoretically skilled doctors, maybe. But the whole idea of medical training taking place at a Catholic institution is anathema to the concept of what Medicine should be about. Good doctors are good because they have their patient’s best interest in mind, without having to take into consideration whether their actions will please or irate a supernatural deity or the Pope.

6 Responses to Catholic theology is no basis for teaching Medicine

  1. Oh dear! A deluded mob of catholic “trained” doctors, who’s main mission I would suggest is to infect their patients with childish nonsense aimed at making catholic inc bigger and more powerful. The good news is they’re losing the race.

  2. Shabako Andrew

    I do not believ what you are saying is right . Don’t write an aticle because you can but do it to help christaindom live every one with his faith and belief. To you they are wrong. Truth is left to God to decide so mind your busness.

  3. I attend a Catholic university and it is a real eye opener. I come from a humanist background, am ex gay (that’s another story ) etc etc I always wondered why Catholics believed what they do. Now I realise they believe our lives are meant for living and getting closer to God. So from this basic premise, abortion is wrong as it does not allow a person to live and get to know God. If you had an abortion, or encouraged someone to have one, know that God loves you a lot and wants to be in your heart.

    On a further note, there is a struggle going on and the Catholics are very aware of it, on one side is Secular Humanism, whose faith you espouse on this page, and Christianity on the other, whose faith the Catholics espouse.

    It is a fascinating battle to watch. On one side is a two thousand year old organisation with over a billion members worldwide, who promotes having children, then educates them in their own schools and universities. On the other a few thousand people online with apathetic adherents, who aren’t too keen on having large families. I know who I am betting will endure and come out the other end in say one hundred years or so. One hundred years is not a long time compared to two thousand…

  4. Micheal,
    How handy for you that you just happened to be born in the right place, where the locals believe in the only true religion. Amazingly there are Catholic universities for you to attend! What a stroke of luck! How fortunate for you that you didn’t find yourself in India and having to put up with all those Budhists (a belief system of some 2500 years standing), or those deluded bloody Hindus who keep banging on about their billion followers and how their Holy Vedas were written 3500 years ago.
    If longevity is the selling point for your religion, you’re not on the winning team.

    Unfortunately your 2000 years is not long in the great scheme of things. Ancient Egyptian civilisation lasted around 3000 years. No dought they thought their gods were true and that they’d last forever. Not to mention the Greeks and the Romans.

    As an athiest I’m not only amazed that people continue to believe in gods, but that they think everyone else’s gods are silly, while their own god is true.
    One thing is for sure, no matter how much you believe in it, your religion will die out eventually just like all the rest.

    Your god doesn’t love me or want to be in my heart. He wants me to burn in Hell for all eternity for not believing in Him.
    He also wants me to overpopulate the world by having a baby every time I have sex.
    He wants me to get AIDS and other STDs because having sex using a condom would stop the baby production.

    Far from being apathetic, I think most atheists by definition have had to do a lot more thinking than you religionists. Like you, most believers just go with the religion they were born into. Not much thought required there. Religionists do what they’re told by their men in dresses and their holy books. Atheists must discover their own moral compass.

    And don’t give me that “ex gay” malarky. So you had a few dalliances as a teenager while you were finding your sexuality, but now you’re pretty much straight. Well good for you, but I hope you’re not going to insult gay people by suggesting it’s a curable “condition”?
    Isn’t “Catholic university” an oxymoron anyway?

  5. 'Tis Himself

    On a further note, there is a struggle going on and the Catholics are very aware of it, on one side is reality, whose faith you espouse on this page, and delusion and bigotry on the other, whose faith the Catholics espouse.

    Fixed it for you, Michael.

    By the way, we might get a modicum of respect for the Catholic Church when it decides its prestige and dignity are less important than the welfare of children. Until then, you can take the Catholic Church and ram it up your rosy red rectum.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>