Michael Nugent means well. He is sincerely concerned about the effect that the Deep Rifts™ in the skeptic and atheist movements are having on the groundwork being done by advocacy groups. And that’s fair enough and a noble cause.
But these Deep Rifts™, with all the personal animosities, broken bridges and blog trench wars that have come with it in the last 2 years in the wake of the Dublin Atheist Convention, are not as Michael seems to believe the result of disagreements on an intellectual level that can be addressed with the tools of reason and rationality. To understand this we have to remember for a moment how this all started. By Rebecca Watson making a throwaway comment in a Youtube clip about moving house. “Guys don’t do that“. That’s it. That’s all.
Michael Nugent has recently written a series of posts where he made an attempt to address these issues, he invited the 2 “parties” to rational dialogue, and I am convinced that he really means to solve this issue by ways of rational discussion and reasoning. But this can not work. Continue reading


